Could Pirates Send Four Pitchers To MLB All-Star Game?

All eyes are on Paul Skenes in Pittsburgh, but he is not the only Pirates pitcher earning a serious All-Star look.

David Bednar’s season began in disaster—a blowup on Opening Day and a swift demotion to Triple-A. But since returning in mid-April, he has reemerged as the closer Pirates fans expect. The right-hander has reclaimed his role and reasserted himself as one of the game’s most effective relievers. As Noah Wright of Rum Bunter notes, Bednar has been “one of baseball’s best relievers upon his return to the big leagues.” If the trend holds, a third All-Star appearance is well within reach.

The Pirates would not have stayed afloat without Dennis Santana, who stepped in quietly but capably. He has closed games with poise and continues to post standout numbers, especially in high-leverage moments. Santana has achieved success in late innings by limiting walks, keeping the ball in the yard and forcing weak contact. Despite his lack of name recognition, his performance speaks for itself.

He is not a strikeout artist, but he prevents damage—the kind of arm managers want tucked into an exhibition bullpen.

Then there is Bailey Falter, perhaps the team’s most unexpected All-Star candidate. Picked up in a quiet deadline trade nearly two years ago, Falter has become a rotation mainstay. He posted the lowest single-month ERA by a Pirates starter in franchise history this May (0.76), thanks to his control, pitch efficiency and ability to work deep into games.

Skenes may be the Pirates’ marquee attraction in Atlanta next month, but do not overlook the quieter contenders making a serious case of their own.

More MLB: Pirates Already Promoted Two Top Prospects: These Names Could Be Next